SIGN UP LOG IN
 

Illegal online gambling: banks cannot justify themselves

Published by

June 10, 2019 7:27 am

gambling

Payment service providers are prohibited from participating in transactions related to illegal online gambling. But now the Leverkusen District Court has also made it clear that banks cannot invoke the use of an automated process to carry out such transactions as justification.

In its ruling of 21 February 2018 – Ref.: 158 C 19107/17 – the AG Munich confirmed approximately one year ago that banks violated the prohibition of participation in credit card payments in connection with illegal online gaming pursuant to Section 4 (1) sentence 2 2nd half sentence GlüStV 2012. As a result, they lose their payment claims against their customers.

No claim for reimbursement of expenses for banks

In the case of credit card payments, the bank first pays in advance and transfers the transaction amount to the payment recipient – in this case to the online gaming provider. Depending on the type of contract, the bank collects the amount either immediately or at an agreed later date from the customer’s deposited current account. This is referred to as the bank’s claim for reimbursement of expenses.

However, the AG Munich decided that the bank would not be entitled to any reimbursement of expenses if it infringed a legal prohibition in a transaction – as in the case of payments in connection with illegal online gambling.

In a lawsuit conducted by the law firm Lenné, the AG Leverkusen confirmed the opinion of the AG Munich on February 19, 2019, but emphasized a further legal aspect in its decision. In the case of an existing statutory ban, it is up to the banks to take appropriate precautions to ensure that they do not violate the ban. AG Leverkusen held this view as follows:

“Due to the law applicable in Germany to the organization of gambling, it was incumbent upon the plaintiff to take precautions not to violate this and not to cooperate in payments prohibited in connection with illegal gambling. To that end, it must draw up contracts with its contracting undertakings accordingly, i.e. exclude payment obligations for games of chance organised in Germany without authorisation, and ensure that this is the case in fact.” (AG Leverkusen, judgment of 19.02.2019 – Ref.: 26 C 346/18, emphasis by the law firm)

Automated procedures: no justification

The view of AG Leverkusen that banks cannot justify themselves by referring to the use of an automated procedure is particularly noteworthy. A fully automated mass transaction does not release banks from their obligation to comply with applicable law:

“It cannot successfully object to this, saying that the payment procedure is fully automated. In the case of an automated procedure, payments to gambling providers initiated automatically in Germany by credit card can also be blocked without permission. Moreover, the use of an automated procedure does not release the user from the obligation to comply with applicable law. Rather, this must also be complied with in such procedures or otherwise not to be used.” (AG Leverkusen, judgment of 19.02.2019 – Ref.: 26 C 346/18, emphasis by the law firm)

Like the AG München, the AG Leverkusen was also of the opinion that transactions in connection with illegal online gaming could be easily identified as such by the bank using the Merchant Category Code (MCC) and the “White List” of the gaming supervisory authorities of the federal states.

In this regard, the AG Leverkusen:

“For the plaintiff, it was also obvious and liquid evidence that the defendant had claimed for a legally prohibited event fee from its contractual partners and that it was legally forbidden for the plaintiff to participate in payment transactions. This already results from the fact that the defendant used the card in Germany and the payments to its customers were marked with the Merchant Category Code (MCC) 7995, which stands for bets (including lottery tickets, casino gaming chips), i.e. gambling. The fact that its contractual partners, whose business it thus knew, are not allowed to organise games of chance in Germany could be established by inquiry to the competent authorities or from the “White List of the gambling authorities of the countries: Gambling provider with a permit in Germany ” published on the Internet by the Joint Office for Gambling of the Federal States since the end of 2015 and continuously updated. (AG Leverkusen, judgment of 19.02.2019 – Ref.: 26 C 346/18)

The judgment of the AG Leverkusen is to be regarded as groundbreaking, even if it remains to be seen how the case law will develop. After all, there is still no supreme court jurisdiction on the subject.

The law firm Lenné will gladly fight for you to recover your payments to illegal gambling providers by taking civil action against the credit card banks. For an initial assessment, the law firm is at your disposal free of charge. Simply make an appointment for an initial, non-binding consultation.

More News

Esports: G2 reaches MSI semi-finals

Esports: G2 reaches MSI semi-finals

Even a defeat in the League of Legends Mid-Season Invitationals' eighth group match cannot stop G2 from reaching the semi-finals.…

Erich Kollmann in the final of the partypoker Grand Prix Million King's!

Erich Kollmann in the final of the partypoker Grand Prix Million King's!

With 1,958 entries there was an overlay at the partypoker Grand Prix Million. In the final €164.300 are waiting for…

Groups drawn, The International 2019 begins

Groups drawn, The International 2019 begins

Dramatic encounters await the audience in the group phase of The International 2019 (TI9). KuroKy' and Team Liquid will meet…

PUBG Mobile Club Open 2019: Tencent unveils final teams before release

PUBG Mobile Club Open 2019: Tencent unveils final teams before release

We now know the complete list of teams that will participate in the final round of the PUBG Mobile Club…

PUBG: Gen.G crowned World Champion 2019

PUBG: Gen.G crowned World Champion 2019

The PUBG World Champion 2019 is confirmed! Korea is again in the race, and Gen.G esports can now call itself…

New Working Group

New Working Group "Women in eSport" of the eSport Federation Germany

At the Networking Breakfast for women at the Gamesweek, which took place two weeks ago in Berlin, 25 women met.…

E-Sport News: Virtus.pro takes over AVANGAR

E-Sport News: Virtus.pro takes over AVANGAR

The Russian eSports organization Virtus.pro sacks its Polish CS:GO team and hires CIS team from AVANGAR. For the payment of…

CS:GO Asia Championships 2019

CS:GO Asia Championships 2019

From 20th to 24th November the CS:GO Asia Championships 2019 will take place in Shanghai. The tournament consists of eight…

Because of Nazi greeting, Van Basten deleted from FIFA20

Because of Nazi greeting, Van Basten deleted from FIFA20

The terrible derailment of Marco van Basten (55) has further consequences. Now "EA Sports" removed Hollands former striker star from…

LEC establishes Berlin as a European eSports Centre

LEC establishes Berlin as a European eSports Centre

The summer season of the League of Legends European Championship (LEC) begins in Berlin on Friday. Five years ago, the…

Apex Legends Season 2 - Can this do anything?

Apex Legends Season 2 - Can this do anything?

Several novelties have been announced for the second season of Apex Legends, which started in early July. Enough to fill…

The fight for the LEC playoffs has begun

The fight for the LEC playoffs has begun

In the sixth week of the European League of Legends League LEC, the battle for playoff places has continued. While…

Strict conditions for Japan's first casino licenses
Strict conditions for Japan's first casino licenses

Japan's government has set the course for the first legalization of land-based casinos on domestic soil. Yesterday, Tuesday, the standards…

Swiss eSports Weekly: The highest prize money in eSports history!
Swiss eSports Weekly: The highest prize money in eSports history!

Although eSports is still relatively young, prize money is distributed that is otherwise difficult to find. This weekend there was…

Dallas Call of Duty shows Roster
Dallas Call of Duty shows Roster

The team ", Dallas Call of Duty," introduced this week every day a new player of their five-headed roster for…

Devilfish Cup - Perfect start for Niko Koop
Devilfish Cup - Perfect start for Niko Koop

As part of the World Poker Tour Nottingham, the Devilfish Cup has been taking place since yesterday at the famous…

Real Madrid - Sergio Ramos: Contract extension?
Real Madrid - Sergio Ramos: Contract extension?

Real Madrid's Sergio Ramos has leaked that his Blancos extension is not his fault, but the fault of the club.…

CS:GO Asia Championships 2019
CS:GO Asia Championships 2019

From 20th to 24th November the CS:GO Asia Championships 2019 will take place in Shanghai. The tournament consists of eight…

Ronaldo as Bundesliga nightmare
Ronaldo as Bundesliga nightmare

Cristiano Ronaldo is the spectre of the Bundesliga. The five-time world footballer has an impressive record against German teams in…

Are the worldwide tournament series obsolete?
Are the worldwide tournament series obsolete?

Poker is played all over the world. But still, you can only bring players from A to B to a…

Apex Legends Season 2 - Can this do anything?
Apex Legends Season 2 - Can this do anything?

Several novelties have been announced for the second season of Apex Legends, which started in early July. Enough to fill…

The PokerStars Sunday Million today for $109 as Progressive Knockout!
The PokerStars Sunday Million today for $109 as Progressive Knockout!

After the large success of the WCOOP on PokerStars, it continues with the industry leader on Sunday 29th September equal…

Mybetting Deals Tools

Surebet by BetBurger

Surebet by BetBurger

BetBurger is a service focusing on arbitrage bets, also known as sure bets. It turns sports betting into an investment.

Matched Betting by OddsMonkey

OddsMonkey

OddsMonkey offers matched betting services with features to enhance your profits with the best betting offers.

Live Sport Results and Statistics

Live Scores

Always keep ahead of the sports betting game with our real time results and statistics!

2000+ Free Slots

Play the best online slots and your favourites from the biggest developers for free right here!